My Therapist Is Judging Me - And Why Your Brain Makes You Think It's Your Fault
If you're sitting in therapy feeling like your therapist is silently judging every word you say, you're not alone—and you're not imagining things. Research shows that it happens too often. But here's what makes this even more complicated: if you're in therapy, you're already in a psychologically vulnerable state, which makes your brain more likely to interpret neutral responses as criticism and blame yourself when something feels off.
The truth is more nuanced than "trust your therapist" or "fire them immediately." Understanding why judgment happens, why you're wired to assume it's your fault, and how to tell the difference between real judgment and your own psychological vulnerabilities can help you take control of your therapeutic experience.
The Research: You're Not Making This Up
Among clients who had a negative experience in psychotherapy, 33% perceived their therapist as judgmental. This isn't a small minority of "difficult" clients.
Psychotherapists sincerely want to help their clients. Despite their best efforts, however, they do have biases that may affect clinical assessment, reasoning, and decision-making, often functioning outside the therapist's conscious awareness. Your therapist may genuinely believe they're being supportive while their nonverbal communication tells a different story.
Studies on cognitive and affective biases in psychotherapy reveal that therapist judgment isn't just about personal prejudices—it's about how human brains process information under stress. When therapists are overwhelmed, burned out, or triggered by content that resembles their own unresolved issues, their ability to maintain genuine neutrality becomes compromised.
Why Your Brain Is Working Against You
Here's the psychological double-bind that makes this situation so confusing: the very conditions that bring people to therapy—depression, anxiety, trauma, low self-esteem—make you more prone to self-blame and hypervigilant to signs of rejection.
Research consistently shows a significant relationship between self-blame and psychological distress. People with depression are particularly susceptible to experiencing moral emotions like guilt and shame, while those with anxiety become hyperalert to social threats. If you're in therapy, your brain is already primed to assume that uncomfortable moments are your fault.
Therapy clients describe experiencing "feelings of vulnerability that led to desire to disengage" and report intense "self-blame, hatred, doubt, guilt, and shame" during treatment. This means that even when your therapist genuinely isn't judging you, your psychological state may interpret their neutral responses as criticism.
The Wounded Healer Dynamic
Understanding your therapist's psychology helps clarify why judgment happens and why it's often not personal. The concept of the "Wounded Healer" has long been recognized in mental health research—many therapists enter the field because of their own personal struggles and trauma history.
Research shows, for example, that therapists’s personal trauma may be activated by client stories. As your therapist takes your perspective and your emotions as conscientious providers, they may also remember their own suffering. As a result, they may unconsciously distance themselves as a protective mechanism — which may seem like judgment to you.
Fatigue expands emotional cracks. Between 21% and 61% of mental health providers show signs of burnout. This doesn't mean therapists are bad people—it means they're human beings doing emotionally demanding work, often without adequate support or recovery time.
Studies consistently demonstrate that therapist burnout significantly affects treatment outcomes, explaining 31-39% of therapist effectiveness. When therapists are depleted, their capacity for genuine empathy, curiosity, and non-judgmental presence becomes compromised, regardless of their training or intentions.
How to Tell the Difference: Real Judgment vs. Your Brain's Interpretation
Signs of Actual Therapist Judgment:
Verbal indicators:
"You should know better than that"
"I can't believe you did that again"
"That's not healthy" (without exploration or curiosity)
Frequent use of "should" or "shouldn't" statements
Comparing you unfavorably to other clients
Religious or moral pronouncements about your choices
Nonverbal signs:
Eye rolling, head shaking, or visible frustration
Leaning away when you discuss certain topics
Facial expressions that don't match their supportive words
Checking time frequently during sensitive discussions
Body language that becomes closed or defensive
Pattern recognition:
Consistently steering you away from certain topics
Becoming less engaged when you discuss specific areas of your life
Offering quick solutions instead of exploring your feelings
Seeming relieved when you don't bring up particular subjects
Signs It Might Be Your Psychological State:
Self-awareness check:
You feel judged in multiple relationships, not just therapy
You're going through a particularly vulnerable period
You've recently shared something you feel ashamed about
You're comparing your therapist's response to what you wished they'd said
You're reading judgment into neutral statements or silence
Reality testing questions:
Has your therapist explicitly said anything judgmental?
Are their suggestions practical rather than moral pronouncements?
Do they ask follow-up questions rather than shutting down topics?
Have they remained consistent in their supportive stance over time?
What to Say When You Feel Judged
Script for direct feedback: "I noticed that when I was talking about [specific topic], I felt like you might be judging me. I know I'm in a vulnerable place right now and sometimes my brain assumes the worst, but I wanted to check this out with you. Can you help me understand your reaction?"
Follow-up if they dismiss your concern: "I appreciate that you don't intend to be judgmental. At the same time, I'm feeling judged, and that's affecting my ability to be open in here. Can we talk about what might help me feel safer to share difficult things?"
If they become defensive: "I'm not attacking your character—I'm trying to make our work together more effective. When I feel judged, I shut down, and that doesn't help either of us. How can we address this together?"
Script for specific incidents: "Earlier when you said [specific words] or when your expression changed, I felt criticized. Help me understand what was happening for you in that moment."
When Good Intentions Aren't Enough
Therapists genuinely want to help and have good intentions. However, good intentions don't eliminate unconscious bias, burnout-related emotional exhaustion, or unresolved personal issues that get triggered in sessions. A therapist can simultaneously care about your wellbeing and struggle with their own judgmental reactions.
Research shows that therapists are more likely to attribute premature treatment termination to client characteristics than to their own behavior—a classic example of self-serving bias. This means your therapist may be genuinely unaware of how their judgment affects you, even when it's obvious to you.
The wounded healer dynamic creates another layer of complexity. When therapists haven't fully processed their own trauma or shame, client stories can trigger defensive reactions that show up as judgment. Your therapist might be protecting themselves emotionally rather than consciously criticizing you.
Understanding this dynamic helps you respond more effectively. Instead of assuming malicious intent, you can address the behavior directly while acknowledging the human limitations that contribute to it.
Protecting Yourself Without Burning Bridges
Document patterns: Keep brief notes about when you feel judged, including specific triggers, your therapist's words or reactions, and your emotional response. Patterns become clearer over time and help you distinguish between isolated incidents and systemic issues.
Set boundaries around sensitive topics: "I need to talk about [topic], and I need to know that you can remain curious and non-judgmental about it. Can you do that right now, or should we wait until another session?"
Request explicit reassurance when needed: "I'm about to share something I feel a lot of shame about. Before I do, can you remind me that your job is to understand, not to judge whether my choices were right or wrong?"
Use your therapy time strategically: If certain topics consistently trigger judgment, consider whether this therapist is the right fit for exploring those areas. You might address surface-level issues with them while finding a specialist for more sensitive work.
Troubleshooting Common Scenarios
"My therapist says they're not judging me, but I still feel judged" Trust your experience while also considering your psychological state. Ask for specific reassurances: "Can you help me understand your facial expression when I mentioned [topic]?" Sometimes therapists are processing difficult emotions and need to be more aware of their nonverbal communication.
"I think my therapist judges my lifestyle choices" Distinguish between clinical observations and moral judgments. A therapist pointing out that your drinking affects your sleep isn't the same as judging you as a person. Ask: "Are you concerned about my behavior because it affects my mental health goals, or do you disapprove of it morally?"
"I feel judged about my past but not my current issues" This pattern often indicates therapist discomfort with trauma or behavior they can't relate to. Consider whether they have adequate training for your specific experiences. Past judgment doesn't mean they're a bad therapist—they might just be outside their competence area.
"My therapist seems to judge some clients but not others" Pay attention to what triggers their judgment. If it's consistently around issues you share (sexual orientation, religious beliefs, lifestyle choices), that's a red flag. If it seems random, it might indicate burnout or personal stress affecting their work.
Taking Control of Your Therapeutic Experience
Remember: you're not responsible for your therapist's judgment, but you are responsible for protecting your own mental health. This isn't about being confrontational or demanding—it's about being an informed consumer of mental health services.
Your action plan:
Reality-check your perceptions using the criteria above
Address judgment directly using the scripts provided
Document patterns to distinguish isolated incidents from systemic problems
Set protective boundaries around sensitive topics
Consider your options if judgment continues despite direct feedback
When to stay and work on it:
Your therapist acknowledges the dynamic and works to change it
The judgment is limited to specific areas rather than pervasive
You're making progress in other areas of therapy
They're willing to get consultation about their reactions
When to consider switching therapists:
They dismiss your feedback about feeling judged
The judgment affects your ability to be honest in sessions
You're spending therapy time managing their emotional reactions
Progress has stalled due to the judgmental dynamic
The Bottom Line: You Deserve Genuine Acceptance
Feeling judged in therapy is common, understandable, and often not entirely in your imagination. Your brain's vulnerability makes you more sensitive to criticism, while your therapist's human limitations may create subtle judgment despite good intentions. Neither dynamic is your fault, but both require your attention.
You deserve a therapeutic relationship where you can explore difficult topics without fear of criticism. While perfect neutrality may be impossible, basic respect and curiosity about your experiences should be non-negotiable. If you consistently feel judged despite addressing it directly, remember that there are thousands of therapists who can provide the acceptance and support you need.
Trust your instincts, advocate for yourself, and don't settle for a therapeutic relationship that leaves you feeling worse about yourself. Good therapy exists—and recognizing judgment is the first step toward finding it.
Research Sources
Curran, J., et al. (2019). “How Does Therapy Harm? A Model of Adverse Process Using Task Analysis in the Meta-Synthesis of Service Users' Experience.” Frontiers in Psychology, 13;10:347.
Klatte, R., et al. (2018). “Adverse effects of psychotherapy: protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis.” Systematic Reviews, 8;7:135.
Merino, Y., Adams, L., & Hall, W. J. (2018). "Implicit Bias and Mental Health Professionals: Priorities and Directions for Research." Psychiatric Services, 69(6), 723–725.
Prasko, J., et al. (2021). “The use and misuse of power in cognitive-behavioral therapy, schema therapy, and supervision.” Neuroendocrinology Letters, 28;46(1):33-48.
Yager, J., & Kay, K. (2021). "Clinicians' Cognitive and Affective Biases and the Practice of Psychotherapy." American Journal of Psychotherapy, 1;74(3):119-126.
Mandangu, C., et al. (2024/2025). "Implicit bias in referrals to relational psychological therapies: review and recommendations for mental health services." Front Public Health. 7:12:1469439.
Yager, J., et al. (2021). "Clinicians’ Cognitive and Affective Biases and the Practice of Psychotherapy." American Journal of Psychotherapy, Vol. 74, No. 3
Morse, G., et al. (2012) “Burnout in Mental Health Services: A Review of the Problem and Its Remediation.” Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 39(5):341–352.
Jannati, Y., Sharif Nia, H., Froelicher, E. S., Goudarzian, A. H., & Yaghoobzadeh, A. (2020). "Self-Blame Attributions of Patients: A Systematic Review Study." Central Asian Journal of Global Health, 9(1):e419.
Zaccari, V., et al. (2024). "Understanding Self-Criticism: A Systematic Review and Synthesis." Clinical Neuropsychiatry, 21(6):455–476.
Šoková, B., Greškovičová, K., Halamová, J., & Baránková, M. (2025). "Breaking the vicious cycles of self-criticism: a qualitative study on the best practices of overcoming one’s inner critic." BMC Psychology, 13, 266.
Capaldi, K., Elliott, R. (2024). "Negative treatment of self in socially anxious clients." Person-Centered & Experiential Psychotherapies, (23) 101-121.